I can't
change the world;
I'm barely
able to change my mind.
But I
can change
where I stand.
And if someone chooses to
stand by me,
two worlds have changed,
two new ways of seeing
are created.
We can,
if we are skilled enough
or lucky enough, get our students
to stand with us at the
edge of the
reflecting pool,
kneel down, and
look deeply
into themselves.
What they see
is more true than
anything said about them.
What they see
is undeniable and
needs to be accepted.
What they see
can be shaped,
cleaned, and polished.
What they see
is okay.
No, dear ones,
you can't
change the world;
but we can change where we stand.
And if we each hold a mirror
we might convince
the whole world to
take a deeper look.
-----
This piece was written during the Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute this past July.
Showing posts with label GMWP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GMWP. Show all posts
Monday, December 09, 2013
Friday, December 06, 2013
new poem - Concert On The Square
| "...old couples emboldened with swinging harmonica vibrations lean into each other." --photo is of Robert Bonfiglio, who performed at a concert on the square in Madison this summer |
emboldened with swinging harmonica vibrations
lean into each other.
We all could.
Maybe you prefer to sing a child's song,
making up a new language, and
leaning to reach the most demanding notes.
We all could.
After the music fades, some might choose to speak
a verse that moves the crowd to
lean closer, feeling the whispered sadness.
We all could.
The reflected sun shifts though the crowd,
lands on faces, and makes them glow;
we all could.
-----
I started writing this piece while attending the Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute this past July.
Monday, December 02, 2013
new poem - "Opportunity Awaits You Next Monday"
![]() |
| "On next Monday, we'll solve all our problems. Next Monday, we'll end all our longings." |
win that award.
Next Monday, I'll
bust down the door.
Next Monday, I'll
finish my novel.
Next Monday, I'll
learn about loving.
On next Monday, you'll
have to choose.
Next Monday, you'll
be the one to lose.
Next Monday, you'll
see how it feels.
Next Monday, you'll
be crushed under our wheels.
On next Monday, we'll
solve all our problems.
Next Monday, we'll
end all our longings.
Next Monday, we'll
find space in our life.
Next Monday, we'll
forget who is right.
-----
This is a piece I started for a write-in during this past summer's Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute. It was inspired by a fortune cookie slip.
Tuesday, October 22, 2013
A Place Of Respite In A Chaotic World
I was settling into the routine of the classroom as a student teacher on Tuesday, September 11, 2001. As much as I wanted to panic, I had to remain calm. One young woman chose to stay with me in the “quiet” room rather than watch the news because her mother worked for the Department of Defense and was in the Pentagon that day. It took seven days to find out her mother was alive and well.
I will never forget the intensity of that day and those that immediately followed. I learned that regardless of maturity level, the students still need me to set the emotional thermostat of the room. The content that I teach is important; the content of my character as a model for my students is more important. It wouldn't be right to say I find something to “love” in each of my high school students. For one thing, they can be annoying, egotistical, and confrontational. However, I believe my students need me to acknowledge their humanity while calmly leading our learning efforts.
I sometimes think of my students as characters in a novel; I am naturally drawn to the characters that experience the greatest change in personality, understanding, and/or disposition. Even my dependable, stable, and focused students are coping with the difficult transition from childhood to young adulthood. Some students have to deal with additional upheavals in their world as well; I am fascinated by the resiliency and drive of these students who must struggle. I know that I have something to learn in their successes and their failures.
At first it was a continual battle to get Steve to take off his hat, and when he took it off, the hat magically popped back on his head. As a “reader” of this character I inferred that the hat was about something more to him but I had to be careful not to jump to conclusions. Over a quarter we developed a good working relationship because I remained calm and took time to talk about his interests. He would take his hat off for me and take part in class.
When Steve's mother came in for parent teacher conferences she gave me more pieces of his story. She started crying as she told me about how they had been homeless for the previous three months. Steve's hat, an adolescent version of a security blanket, was one of few things he owned. Steve couldn't explain it to me; emotions are confusing like that. If I had yelled, written him up, sent him to the office, or in some other way broken our relationship over a ridiculous hat policy, he would have never worked for me again. I would have crushed his already weak ego.
I am only part of a small segment of my students’ developmental journey. Often I am reminded that the goal is progress not perfection. My students appreciate having a calm, kind, and understanding person to turn to in their chaotic lives; for some, my classroom is the only respite they get from a noisy world that reduces them to a set of numbers.
Wednesday, August 07, 2013
Five Lessons From The Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute
I spent the month of July taking part in the Greater Madison Writing Project's summer institute. I know that the interactions with my 14 fellow participants and the three site facilitators is only the start of GMWP's influence on my life, my career, and my abilities as a teacher.
While the topics explored ranged widely there were five ideas that wove through every conversation, workshop, and sharing session. These are insights that became clearer every day because we were living them; my experience in that month of the institute proved these things to me.
![]() |
| 3330 Atwood Ave., Madison Wisconsin is where Olbrich Botanical Gardens is located and where the GMWP holds its summer institute. |
Collaborative inquiry around individual interests trumps top down initiatives.
Why would anyone want to spend a month of their summer in professional development? There are the obvious reasons of working toward a degree, getting trained to use some new system, or earning credit for license renewal. While GMWP does provide six credits, this is not why I was so eager to be involved. I was intrigued by the prospect of being encouraged to explore any aspect of writing instruction I desired. I had never had this experience in my undergraduate work nor in my teaching experience. Sure, I had experience with teaching technology related professional development and my district had held a "literacy camp" that was lightly attended. This summer institute was different.
I wasn't expected to be an expert in my topic. I wasn't expected to be able to answer all the questions. That was the point. The work I had to put in before leading my teachers workshop (inquiry session) was to develop a question and research an answer to the point where I could share my initial findings with the group. In each session we further explored the topic. This model allowed me to bring my passion and interest in a topic into a room of education professionals and share what insights I had while also benefiting from all of their perspectives and experience. How cool is that? And more important, how different from what usually passes for "professional development?"
My question was about incorporating the work of Daniel Pink in To Sell Is Human into my professional practice. One of the points Pink makes is that leaders need to recognize the necessity of problem identification. We cannot solve a problem until we really know what it is. This self directed inquiry approach followed by group collaboration allowed each of us to identify a real problem we faced in our classrooms.
How could any of the "professional development" presenters I've been subjected to over the years know what our problems are? I learned in this institute that there are administrators out there willing to allow teachers to pursue inquiry based professional development; we need more of this. Let us work to identify and solve our own problems. However well meaning, outsiders never know us, the problems we deal with, or what we've already tried; their ability to help us is minimal at best.
We teach who we are.
I will get to the corollary ("The students learn who they are") below, but it will help to talk about teachers first. Another teacher in the GMWP summer institute included in her workshop an explanation of the importance of learning styles and how we as teachers need to be aware of how our students might need information in a way that is different from the way we prefer it. This is an important idea to keep in mind, but I believe that we can only stretch ourselves so much before we break. I am reminded of the often quoted advice that Polonius gives Laertes: "To thine own self be true." We do our students a much greater service if we help them develop strategies to cope with learning conditions outside of what is optimal for them. This is one of the ways that students learn who they are.
We have a duty to be aware of our impact on student identity. Students learn who they are at least in part during the experiences they have in our schools. I guess WKCE scores, ACT test results, exam grades, report card grades, etc. have their place. I used to think of them as a necessary evil; lately, however, I've begun to just think of them as just evil.
While I could tell you a handful of stories about students who have gone on to accomplish much more than their ACT score would have indicated they were capable of, I am too troubled by the countless number of students who let a test score, grade report, or some other externally applied label become part of their identities to simply focus on the positives. Since these "necessary" evils aren't going away anytime soon, we need to be very clear what a test result means and what a grade means when we communicate this information to students.
I was excellent at school from my very first days of kindergarten. I always tested above grade level and this fueled my ego and became part of my identity. This carried me through high school, and I graduated with honors and a lot of cords and sashes. College was a shock. I quickly realized that my writing skills were lacking compared to my counterparts. Out of necessity, I learned more about writing in my first year of college than I had since my family first taught me how to form letters before I entered kindergarten. I also realized quickly that I had not read many of the texts I was expected to have already read.
Test scores lie because they tell only a very small part of an individual's story. Our students deserve to know that.
As much as possible, give direction not directions.
The facilitators of the summer institute explained early on the principle of direction not directions. As a student I want the ten steps to check off and the specific requirements to meet. So, this direction not directions thing drove me crazy at first. It took me some time to figure out that this really represented the most respect for my status as a professional I had ever experienced.
In addition to the respect it showed, this approach encouraged creative and varied responses from me and my fellow institute participants. The difference between “student” and “learner” was explored In another workshop session . Direction encouraged us to be learners while directions would have forced us to be students.
I need to make it clear to the learners in my classroom that it is their path to walk and therefore I cannot tell them exactly how to get to the destination. I need to help and guide while allowing them to discover their own strengths and supporting them in their weaknesses. And who knows what unexpected, creative work will come from this approach.
Go for a walk, write a poem, take a yoga class, dance your heart out, or sing a song; live a balanced life.
Teaching is part of who I am. I spend a large amount of time engaged in my professional practice, reflecting on that practice, and refining my approach. But teaching is not the entirety of who I am.
I am also a writer and photographer. It is important that I attend to my relationships with family and friends. I enjoy art museums, gardens, and movies. I am teaching myself to play the ukulele. And so much more.
The more true I am to my needs, do the things I enjoy, and maintain the healthy relationships in my life the better I am at my work. My experience in the GMWP summer institute crystallized a feeling I've had over the last year into a thought: if I work at my own writing, I will be a better teacher of writing and a better human being.
Teachers ARE at the center...act accordingly!
Part of the required reading for the GMWP summer institute was Teachers at the Center by James Gray. In this book, Gray tells the story of the founding of the National Writing Project. As the title suggests, his central philosophy is that teachers are the source for real development and change in education. It is the experiences and passions of teachers that combine in beautiful ways to make an impact on learners.
Gray's revolutionary approach was to put teachers in charge of their own professional development and to give them a space and time in which to share their work with colleagues. I discussed my own experience with this approach above. I've had numerous colleagues sing the praises of Kelly Gallagher and the professional development he provides, and one of the reasons they respect his suggests more than others is because he is still in the classroom. This approach works.
So, when will we accept this truth as a society? Why are there no teachers included in local school board discussions? Why are teachers shut out of the halls of power when decisions about education are being made? I will praise the Wisconsin DPI and the federal Department of Education because they are seeking out teacher voices. But if corporations can have direct contact with policy makers in crafting laws related to their areas of expertise, why aren't teachers involved directly in crafting legislation related to education?
All of these issues are complex. It certainly doesn't make them less complex to involve more people. It does, however, mean that the policy work being done would have a better chance of having a real impact. There is no other profession in recent history that has been as heavily debated and regulated by outsiders and yet so underrepresented by practitioners.
Friday, July 19, 2013
My Friday In The "Institution"
I am taking part in the Greater Madison Writing Project summer institute from July 8 to August 1. Each participant must log the work done during one day of the institute. This is my photo essay log for Friday, July 19.
![]() |
| I am early. I have never mastered the art of showing up "on time." I like it this way. I've found a quiet corner near the stairwell to sit and write a little. |
![]() |
| We relocate to the PC Classroom 348 in the MERIT Library (still in the Teacher Education building). We get logged on and settled in as Christine prepares to start her workshop. |
Tuesday, July 16, 2013
Fifth Way of Looking at Me - Declaration of Independence
In
Institute, July 16, 2013
We
know that each member of the human race is delightfully unique; we
honor and accept those differences in all we do. Though thoroughly
unequal, individual, and unique from birth, each member of the human
species must have the rights to pursue industrious activities to meet
his or her needs, share love in all its nurturing forms, and share
the beauty of his or her humanity through expressive outlets; these
rights should be limited only to ensure the preservation of the same
rights for all.
To
better serve the young people we work with, to establish our rights
and responsibilities as practicing professional teachers, and to
establish a more honest and complete identity for each individual, we
declare our independence from the following:
- Those who would institute practices that interfere with the beliefs stated above
- All people who accept that any human person, a human's experiences, or human potential can be reduced to actionable numbers (see “Yet Another Standardization Movement”)
- Those who harmfully damage the development of a young person by neglect or neglectful coddling (see “But You Don't Know His Home Life”)
- Those who separate themselves from reality so they can maintain an overly simplistic view of the problems we face which allows the myth of simple, miraculous solutions to flourish (see “Let's Just Focus On The Positive”)
- Those who choose to perpetuate this same myth of easily identified and easily solved problems to the public (see “2013 School Board Report: Yet Another Wonderful Year”)
- Anyone unwilling to have a respectful, open discussion that allows for clarity in the identification of real problems (see “What We Need Is Professional Development That Blames The Teachers”)
- Anyone unwilling to share those problems publicly with the appropriate groups to garner empathy, support, and real solutions (see “We Can't Admit We Have Problems and Other Problems For Scared Educators”)
- Those who view the teaching profession as a drain on society, which is in direct conflict with the role education plays in maintaining the shared values of our representative republic (see “My School Experience Was A Waste Of Time Except...”)
- Anyone who views teachers as “those who can't” (see “Any Media Outlet In The Last Ten Years”)
- Any person whose first priority is to sell a system, book, program, or “guaranteed” fix to complex problems (see “Most Professional Development Most Teachers Have Ever Experienced”)
Our
pleas for understanding and requests for dialogue have been met with
stony stares and cold hearts (see “MSD School Board Meeting July
2011). If it is impossible for you to include us in the process of
developing policy and evaluating practice, we will ignore you out of
necessity (see “CCSS Implementation” and “Teacher Effectiveness
Models”). If you make further mandates that make our jobs
impossible, you will lose our services (see “Teacher Retention
Rates” and “Decline in Enrollment in Education Majors”). A far
more dire consequence is the impact this will have on students, on
our future.
Neither
have we been neglectful of our duties to our students. We have
continued our work through all of the hardships (see “Act 10”)
and neglectful leadership (see “I have Outlasted Many
Administrators”). Can we not work together to achieve the common
goal of ensuring the education and futures of our nation's children?
Can we not find common ground and mutual benefit built on compromise?
If we cannot accomplish this, what do we expect our students are
learning about collaboration?
We,
the 2013 cohort of the Greater Madison Writing Project, seek peaceful
resolution of our grievances; absent that, we seek separation from
your tyranny.
When
peaceful talks and collaborative efforts can continue, you know where
to find us; we are the teachers at the center.
Fourth Way Of Looking At Me - Summer of '13 Songbook
I
love all of the albums and songs listed here. The fact that I find
something beautiful in each of them tells you something about me.
In
addition, I have highlighted the lyrics that resonate with me the
most. These are the lines that I will belt out louder than the
performer if I am alone in the car when the song comes on.
In
some cases they are the lines that break my heart because they
capture my own experiences so well.
I
hope you find a song or two to add to your summer listening.
-Carney
A. Lentz
Annotated
Track List
1.
“Hell Yeah” from Out
of Range by
Ani DiFranco
-DiFranco
expresses her unique view of the world by giving glimpses into
genuine moments. The line “sometimes there's some poetry / if you
turn you back long enough / and let it happen naturally” reminds me
I need to live in the moment to appreciate and absorb the beauty
around me.
2.
“Lost” from Theatre
Is Evil by
Amanda Palmer & The Grand Theft Orchestra
-A
quote from this song is also in my “One Last Love Letter.” The
idea that “nothings ever lost forever” challenges everything in
my experience; this is one reason why I like this song.
3.
“Save Me” from Making
Mirrors by
Gotye
-With
all of the changes in my life over the last few years, I've learned
that I'm stronger and more capable than I used to believe. This song
implies that one person inspired the singer to change; for me, the
inspiration to change is from many people. I can, however, still
connect with the emotion expressed here.
4.
“Other Side Of Me” from Laughter
In The Rain
by Neil Sedaka
-One
frustration with choosing to change is that some people never really
see the new me, while those who meet me today have no idea the
struggle it has been to get to this point.
5.
“Please Read The Letter That I Wrote” from Raising
Sand
by Robert Plant & Alison Kraus
-I
love the idea of the letter coming from sleep and the image of the
“well of many words.” This gets at the mysterious and sometimes
completely inexplicable sources of inspiration and insight.
6.
“Telling Stories” from Telling
Stories by
Tracy Chapman
-Chapman
touches on the darker side of how words can be used. She is
expressing this in the context of a failing romantic relationship;
however, the idea that one person can tell a partial truth or leave
to implication a much darker meaning is powerful, and it applies to
all areas of our lives.
7.
“Paperback Writer” from 1
by The Beatles
-The
desperation to have someone appreciate your art and see the meaning
and value of it is a familiar feeling.
8.
“This Is Not A Test” from Volume
One
by She & Him
-It
is the beauty that we leave behind that we are remembered for isn't
it? And that beauty can come I many forms: relationships, children,
lessons taught, artwork, etc.
9.
“Stars” from Some
Nights by
Fun.
-I
never know what to say when people tell me that they have been moved
by my work. What is the proper reaction when “people on the
street...they're telling me that they like what I do now”?
10.
“We May Never Pass This Way Again” from Greatest
Hits by
Seals & Crofts
-Since
we are likely to not pass this way again, what beauty can we
experience and leave behind?
11.
“Going Home” from Old
Ides by
Leonard Cohen
-We
are all just “the brief elaboration of a tube.” Isn't what we
are capable of all the more amazing with that in mind?
12.
“Immortality” from Number
Ones
by Bee Gees
-The
opening lines of this song are undeniably life affirming. I love the
use of “faith” to refer to inward examination (“my faith in who
I am”) rather than a perception of some outward force.
13.
“Heal Yeah!” from 12
Songs by
Neil Diamond
-This
song was a recent discovery for me. It instantly became one of my
favorites. It is the best anthem for a life lived without regret
that I have ever heard.
[What song(s) are the soundtrack for your summer?]
Monday, July 08, 2013
One Last Love Letter - Third Way of Looking At Me
Today would have been Colleen's birthday. Today is also the start of my time at the summer institute for GMWP. So, it seemed fitting to have the third way of looking at me be about Colleen.
----------
----------
July
8, 2013
My
Love,
Today
you would have turned 54, and you have been gone for over three
years. You will never read this. You will never know these words
just as you will never know so much about my life. There is so much
I would tell you, so many experiences I have wished to share with
you, and so many times I have longed for your trusted guidance and
loving arms.
I
know this is supposed to be a “love letter” but I need to first
air some of my regrets. Perhaps on the screen, on paper, or simply
out of my head they will not seem so bad. I wish I had convinced you
to get medical attention earlier. I'm sorry you never got “Up
North” for one more trip, though some of your ashes are in Lac du
Flambeau and Lake Superior. I regret not taking more time away from
work while you were in the hospital. I wish I had been more honest
with you about how ill equipped I was to manage your home care; I
didn't know myself until I saw how the nurses cared for you. I'll
never forget how heart broken you were when I told you that you could
not come home from the hospital; though I know it isn’t true, I
feel like that disappointment helped to spread the infection already
lurking in your system. I’m sorry your father wasn’t with you
when you passed; I should have made them stay. I'm sorry I didn't
hire professional mourners to stand in the back of the church to
wail, rip their clothes, and pull out their hair.
Colleen,
you need to know – I think you knew – I was ready to spend every
day of the rest of my life with you. That was my plan. And I
haven't exactly formulated a new one yet. In the weeks after your
death I asked your friend, Betsy, about how she had moved on after
the death of her Noah. She laughed at the potentially demeaning
nature of her own comment, “You've had dogs die and yet you've been
able to love a new dog right? Well, every person I've loved has been
different in a similar way.” I laughed too because I know she
wasn't comparing our lovers to dogs; she truly sees her animals as
people, members of her family. And the people in our lives enter and
exit at unpredictable times.
In
the three years and two months since you died, I took a quick trip
around the state and into South Dakota to visit places you loved and
leave some of your ashes (sorry, I haven't gotten to Hawaii yet), my
father died, your father died, your mother sold their house, she
moved to Portage, your aunt Lorraine died, I bought a house, I
self-published a book of poetry, I started a writing club at school,
I've lost about 150 pounds (with about 40 or so to go), Mom has had
the farmhouse repainted – blue, I've started to take my photography
more seriously, Joe has been a good friend – you were right about
him, I've went every year to see Marge Gibson release the eagles in
Sauk Prairie, Dalton graduated from college, eventually so did Bug,
Mikal started college working toward a nursing degree, Mikal is still
driving your old car – she is taking good care of it, and so much
more.
This
verse from “Lost” by Amanda Palmer has been going through my mind
a lot lately:
No
one's ever lost forever.
When
they die they go away,
But
they will visit you occasionally.
Do
not be afraid.
No
one's ever lost forever.
They
are caught inside your heart.
If
you garden them and water them,
They
make you what you are.
This
is a song that you never heard by a singer you never heard. I think
you would have liked it and liked her. And it is true. And all the
sappy songs about loss are true. You are gone, but the love remains.
In
my garden you are the oak tree with tiger lilies around its trunk.
Tall, strong, and enduring with flashes of color in spring and fall.
In my garden you provide shade to all and a place to live for all the
little birds. I suspect there might be a cat in your branches as
well – not the Cheshire cat Alice encountered but your cranky
Punkin cat. In my garden you are one of the anchor points around
which everything else must make sense.
Thank
you for being. Thank you for being my love. Thank you for sharing
your time.
Carney
Tuesday, July 02, 2013
Six Word Novel - Second Way Of Looking At Me
My second "Way of Looking at Me" that I had to have ready for the GMWP summer institute. Trying to write a six word novel about your own life is much more difficult than you might think. I went through something like 30 variations some with completely different themes the the one I settled on.
Tuesday, June 18, 2013
Marks - Poem With Photo
Saturday, June 08, 2013
New Poem - Marks
Beaches after the ocean has receded,
my striated shoulders marked
by the surging of the waves.
Once so fat, I now have stretch marks
on my shoulders, a record carved by
the flow of tears.
These are the least grotesque remnants
of an old self; they are beautiful
as reminders.
No tattoos, but I have these.
Not the results of artful choices but
the consequence of bad decisions,
scars.
I rub ink on my body and press it to paper;
the story is one of regret.
-----
For the Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute, I have to show up with three different genre pieces that show some aspect of who I am. I think this might be the poem I use.
my striated shoulders marked
by the surging of the waves.
Once so fat, I now have stretch marks
on my shoulders, a record carved by
the flow of tears.
These are the least grotesque remnants
of an old self; they are beautiful
as reminders.
No tattoos, but I have these.
Not the results of artful choices but
the consequence of bad decisions,
scars.
I rub ink on my body and press it to paper;
the story is one of regret.
-----
For the Greater Madison Writing Project Summer Institute, I have to show up with three different genre pieces that show some aspect of who I am. I think this might be the poem I use.
Sunday, May 05, 2013
New Poem - The Richness I Possess
I do because I can;
I know the power of a life,
the wisdom of a whisper, and
the rightness of joy
- however brief.
I care because
I have been cared about and
know the power of sheltering arms,
comforting words, and
generous actions
- however humble.
I speak truth because
I know the hurtful power of lies,
the destruction of deception, and
the pain of being mislead
- however well intentioned.
I appreciate because
I have crafted my own art and
know the power of loving praise,
honest critiques, and
public display
- however small the audience.
I own the world because
I know it, have laid a claim to it,
logged it in my ledger, and
defend the place where I stand
- however small my footprint.
-----
The above poem was started as part of a writing prompt given at my orientation for the Greater Madison Writing Project's summer institute. We were told to respond to these quotes from Brenda Ueland: "the ways you possess richness...the much-much that is in you...call out and know it and write it."
I know the power of a life,
the wisdom of a whisper, and
the rightness of joy
- however brief.
I care because
I have been cared about and
know the power of sheltering arms,
comforting words, and
generous actions
- however humble.
I speak truth because
I know the hurtful power of lies,
the destruction of deception, and
the pain of being mislead
- however well intentioned.
I appreciate because
I have crafted my own art and
know the power of loving praise,
honest critiques, and
public display
- however small the audience.
I own the world because
I know it, have laid a claim to it,
logged it in my ledger, and
defend the place where I stand
- however small my footprint.
-----
The above poem was started as part of a writing prompt given at my orientation for the Greater Madison Writing Project's summer institute. We were told to respond to these quotes from Brenda Ueland: "the ways you possess richness...the much-much that is in you...call out and know it and write it."



















